carpish's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[Boring Day Sketches 2]

I like it

All the animation was pretty much correct, which is a damn sight more than most submissions. The characters had weight, and proper movement and momentum, and it was a pleasure to watch.

KoLdBLooD responds:

Thank you very much! I'm glad you enjoyed it.

=]

[That's Fishing]

That was interesting

I liked it, good work on the underwater scenes and the swimming animations. Good sounds and a nice little story as well, quite original at that.

grabbelfant responds:

thanks! for reviewing and watching!

[Saints Of Jovaland: Part3]

Well

I guess it doesn't have the effect you were hoping when I just pressed next without reading anything to get to the movie...guess you can blame television for that kind of impatience. 1 Star for effort though, keep trying! One day you might trick somebody.

Sidorio responds:

You should read the reviews for the others. Some people get really pissed over this stuff. Although most of those reviews actually then get deleted for calling us 'gay ass motherfuckers'.

[Vete a la Versh 4]

Haha

That was a quality flash. Very well translated, and it was funny. Not just "omg penguins lololol" funny. Great expressions on their face. Nice work

Darkar responds:

Thank you! Im glad you liked it!

[TTB Vol. 2 "Gettysbear"]

Unexpectedly funny

Hope this doesn't offend you in anyway, but that was surprisingly funny, and often intelligent humor. Good work, nice voice acting and animation style. I loved bearputer.

The plot was surprisingly coherent, despite the fact that it consisted of time traveling bears and I hadn't seen the first part. Criminally under-rated! Oh, and I was hardcore enough for high quality. Believe it.

altffour responds:

I took no offense from your generally positie review. Have a great day!

[Space creature [Short]]

Interesting

I thought the animation was pretty good to be honest, however the standard of art was not on the same level. But I definitely think you got the timing and movements correct, and the sound effects worked really well.

left4blee responds:

Thank you. I'm not much of an artist which you can obviously tell from this animation. I have a decent concept of the basics of animation (anticipation, timing etc) and the sound effects are all thanks to pepper. He did an awesome job.

[Blane]

For a first SWF

That was pretty good and i'm sure others will feel the same. Some of the animation touchs were really nice - like the guy who was smoking outside the door - next time try animating arm and leg movements.

KorboDuo responds:

first seconds slowly

[TouchDwnTurnAround Collab]

Damn good

At first I found the song sickening. Well to be honest, I still do, but it's so damn catchy, and the pretty/heart warming animations have actually made me like this tune. Good job to everyone.

pixeltool is ace.

FrozenFire responds:

Song is pretty different than what NG is used to.

[The Allien part 1]

Not bad

Miles better than many other first time submissions, and trust me, the more you use flash and watch other animations, the more techniques you'll pick up on. You lose a couple of points for the music, and the animation should have been a lot faster.

Keep up the good work.

Bax3r responds:

Well i youse 12 fps so i gess its slow but i cant do more than 12.... : \