carpish's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[A Sign Of Happiness]

Good animation

I liked it, especially towards the end. The animation was nice, the walk cycle was pretty decent considering how difficult they can be. Goodjob, I've always wanted to animate my dreams.

[Legislative Review]

Something amusing

I thought the style you used was interesting, however the animation could have been much better. Despite that, I found myself laughing at the voice acting and how it suited the imagery.

[Narwhals]

Not bad but not great

Well obviously some will find the song light hearted and fun whilst others will just hate it - I tend to waver towards the general disliking side.

However the animation worked well with the song and the quality was pretty good, the only bit which I found remotely funny was, obviously, the "balls" bit.

The music was good quality, just a bit annoying. Not crazy frog annoying, but if I had to be subjected to it repeatedly, it certainly would be.

[There She Is!! final step]

Great Achievement

I found that when watching this series I totally forgot I was on newgrounds watching a flash animation. I could go on, but there isn't much point, I'm pretty sure all the good things to say about this movie have been said already!

[The Real Legend 3]

Really nice work

When it comes to video game based flashes it's often hard to impress but this one really takes it beyond that level of criticism. The animation is superb, each scene has been drawn so well that it far surpases the quality of the source material itself. Add to that the brilliant jokes which were superbly realised, well, full marks.

Frankly if anyone were to say this is less deserving simply because it is a parody then theres not much that can be done for them.

[Metropolis Circuit]

Excellent concept, superbly executed

The world you have created is exceptional, few animators ever go this far. It's obvious how much time has gone into this and I can't see any flaws which is why i'm giving you no less than 10/10.

[All Wound Up]

extreme

so very extreme i liked the animation and the effects such as the speed and gore! very well done practically flawless graphics and also quite disturbing im keeping away from those things

[Yoshi's Jam Session]

couple of funny bits

if you made this to make fun of that crap music then well done, if you like this music then oh dear. The last "song" is terrible as it always has been, yes it was funny , the idea of it when it first appeared but that dwindles after the first time until its just sad. The Flower shy guy bit was funny though